Don’t be dense about city density!

An excellent piece!

From the Savannah Morning News posted June 24, 2017
By Daniel Carey

I recently took a trip to Seattle for a retreat with the leaders of peer preservation organizations from around the country. Seattle is a great city. Not as historic as Savannah, but progressive and full of energy. It’s quite large and growing at a rapid rate. Regardless of its size and scale, Seattle helped put Savannah in perspective for me. Its urban core is very dense, and in that density lies a problem that Savannah may be saddled with… too much of a good thing in one finite, fragile and historic space.

Density is today’s buzzword in planning and development. And it’s good… mostly. Around the country, the development pendulum is swinging back from wasteful suburban sprawl and towards older, close-in neighborhoods. Through decades of preservation work, Savannah has been a national leader in proving that downtowns can be popular live-work-play areas. Demand creates a need for greater density. However, density should not be a password to more at all costs because it is, after all, just that—more.

Downtowns are, by nature, dense. Savannah’s downtown is the densest part of Savannah. Before it has to endure more — in the name of soothing a rash of hotel development — why not explore increased density in other parts of the city that crave it and can better absorb it? Instead of dumping every mediocre development idea on the same square mile because it’s a no-miss investment, why not explore the edges and surrounding neighborhoods (MLK, Jr. Blvd., Montgomery Street, Eastside and Cuyler-Brownville)? Those areas have vacant lots and “grayfields” that crave investment and can handle it. Additional housing in those areas — which are adjacent to downtown and served by public transportation — can fill a need and return a profit. The city should facilitate such development, and tax credits can incentivize the rehabilitation of existing blighted housing.

Creating more affordable housing, respecting historic preservation, and maintaining human scale are not mutually exclusive goals. The National Trust for Historic Preservation’s “Atlas of Re-Urbanism” is a comprehensive, block-by-block study of the American urban landscape. It reveals that areas of older, smaller buildings and mixed-age blocks boast 33 percent more new business jobs, 46 percent more small business jobs, and 60 percent more women- and minority-owned businesses. They are also denser than newer areas.

Moreover, as Boston’s North End and Miami’s Little Havana demonstrate, relatively small human-scale neighborhoods with older fabric are the keys to the successful cities that visionary Jane Jacobs touted. We already have that in Savannah and it’s the real thing, not a 21st century knock off. In agricultural terms, instead of overplanting and exhausting our best soil, we should focus on sustaining it.

So let’s be careful to scrutinize every aspect of proposals and text amendments that call for the wholesale removal of density requirements. Why be skeptical?

Because downtown is not just any place, it’s a National Historic Landmark District… la crème de la crème. For the most part, it retains a human scale. But it’s just a few amendments and variances away from becoming something entirely different. Or should I say the same?

Daniel G. Carey is the president &CEO of the Historic Savannah Foundation.

 

Is The National Register of Historic Places District of Laurel Park in Jeopardy?

 

“I hope any of you who have expressed an interest in “what’s happening!!! ” to my neighborhood Laurel Park will read this. It’s a thumbnail tale but it’s a beginning to the story of the end of something precious. 10 years ago I pursued a legal remedy to what is now occurring in our neighborhood ,,, I was damned as a destroyer because I believed the code then and now in place in Laurel Park in no way reflects the historic character of our neighborhood. The issue is not housing types ( modern vs craftsman vs dutch colonial vs med rev ) but about no diversity in lot size*, no possibility of multi-family like the Spanish Oaks, or bed & breakfasts, or artist studios, > adaptive reuse of historic structures. Next to Dylan Jon Wade Cox fine example of “shotgun vernacular” stand two 500 ft square ” workers ” cottages ( circa 1924 ) Mine is one of them. Built on 3000 square feet it includes a shared garage … a feature of several Owen Burns built homes ( circa 1924 ) on Madison and Columbia Court. A feature that would not be allowed today. Nor could one build on 3000 square feet. The large new built on the corner and the one across from mine are required by code to be built on a suburban lot size of just under 5000 square feet. They are 1,000,000 dollar ( + ) single family homes. The folks now who are running and /or supporting STOP are the very same people who have praised these developments, sat on their hands and allowed this to occur in Laurel Park. STOP’s president and registered agent lives in the neighborhood and has served numerous times on our Board. This is the same Board that led the charge against another important historic structure, the original Sarasota Herald Tribune home to the Women’s Exchange and most egregiously refused to give support to saving the now demolished 7 Gables and in fact actively contributed to it’s demise. At what point will Laurel Park’s National Historic Designation be rescinded?”

Diana Hamilton

 

With regard to the impact of new construction on a National Register District:

The number and scale must not overwhelm a district’s sense of time and place and historical development.

When the State of Florida nominated Laurel Park for National Register District designation the number of contributing structures was just barely enough. The boundaries of the district had to be creatively drawn to exclude some large land parcels and new buildings to make it work.  In addition, to boost the number of contributing buildings, the Womens Exchange and two commercial buildings across from the Exchange were added by the State of Florida’ s preservationist.

In recent years there have been enough demolitions of contributing structures along with the addition of new homes built on vacant sites without regard for their scale to jeopardize this honorific designation.

Here’s hoping the Laurel Park neighborhood’s organized homeowner association board will wake up!

 

Laurel Park Landmark celebrates 91 Years…………

The Sarasota Herald Tribune is celebrating 91 years of publication.  The newspaper’s first home was in the building best known today as the Woman’s Exchange at the corner of Oak Street and Orange Avenue.  Read the article in today’s paper….

An earlier post on the building…………

WE1

Woman’s Exchange

 

A landmark in Sarasota and an anchor building in Laurel Park’s national historic district – The Woman’s Exchange.  The not-for-profit organization benefiting the arts has occupied the building since 1969.

we5

539 S. Orange Avenue – Building in the rear is todays spanish Oak Apartments

 

The structure was constructed in 1925 for the Sarasota Herald Newspaper – today’s Sarasota Herald-Tribune, our city’s longest running newspaper.  This building, along with several industrial and commercial buildings, and the Sarasota County Courthouse, which was briefly housed on Oak Street, created a pocket of commerce in a growing residential area during Florida’s Land boom.

WE2Sarasota Herald Building

 

In the 1980’s the city surveyed and inventoried its historic properties and selected 24 buildings that it felt exemplified Sarasota’s history to be preserved for future generations.  Those 24 properties became the first in Sarasota to be honored by inclusion on our nation’s most prestigious list of valuable historic buildings and sites – The National Register of Historic Places.  The Woman’s Exchange building is one of those honored properties.

 

 

Owen Burns Legacy in Laurel Park……..

In Sunday’s Sarasota Herald Tribune historian Jeff LaHurd offered readers an excellent article titled  –The Legacy of Owen Burns.  

In the Laurel Park National Register of Historic Places District the legacy of Owen Burns lives on………..

Oak Street between Osprey Avenue and Washington Boulevard bisects the Washington Park Subdivision.  It is just one of many subdivisions that make up today’s Laurel Park National Register of Historic Places District.

Owen Burns ad 1924

The plat of the Washington Park Subdivision was recorded in February 1925.  It was owned and developed by Owen Burns. A number of homes built by Owen Burns dot the subdivision along with some of the preserved  brick paving, sidewalks and curbing.

Washington Park

One of Laurel Park’s most distinguished residences was designed by architect, Dwight James Baum.  Today it is one of only two buildings in the national historic district that is individually designated historic by the National Register of Historic Places.

Kennedy House

 Dr. Kennedy House at Oak and Columbia.

Owen Burns and Dwight James Baum_2

This remains one of my favorite photos.  Mr. Owen Burns and Mr. Dwight James Baum (right) are captured in front of the realty office next to the El Vernona.

el vernona-0

A wonderful panorama of the  Burns Reality Office and the El Vernona Hotel shortly after completion.

map

A great perspective of the early Sarasota landmarks.

If you are interested in viewing more vintage photographs of Sarasota visit the William Hartman Gallery on Palm Avenue.  Mr. Hartman has an incredible collection  on display.  If you want to read more about Sarasota’s history, pick up one or more of Jeff LaHurd’s books at one of our local bookstores.

 

Sarasota’s Iconic Sea Horses….

 

Seahorse-lido

These sea horses never appeared in Laurel Park however residents of the neighborhood frequented Lido Beach and the Casino complex during the 40’s, 50’s and 60’s and knew them well.

Lido Pavillon 1

The majestic eight-foot tall sea horses first appeared in Sarasota at the Lido Beach Casino. They were the design of the building’s architect, Ralph Twitchell. The sea horses were cast of concrete in molds created from full-sized, hand drawn templates. They were then attached to the façade of the casino to create an eye-catching motif on the second story promenade of the building. For almost 30 years they stood as sentinels casting an eye out to sea and affording the perfect backdrop for a magical photo portrait in paradise.

original S-horses

The Lido Casino was demolished in 1969. Before it was completely razed a number of the sea horses were carefully removed. They are privately owned. The building is gone, the sea horses disappeared from sight but the memory of them remained for all who enjoyed the marvelous Lido Casino complex.

Picture 61-1

A cherished photograph is of Esther Williams hanging off one of the marvelous horses at the Casino.  She was in Sarasota taking a break from shooting a Tarzan movie in Florida.

5X7seahorse-med

In the 1980’s the developer of the Quay project on Sarasota’s bayfront brought the delightful iconic figure back to the community. The majestic sea horses were again cast in concrete, from the original design and attached to the Sarasota Quay. The Quay opened in 1987 with eleven sea horses adorning its entryway and main plaza.

IMG_437

Once again these magical statues became the backdrop for photographic portraits. Visitors and residents, young and old came to the Quay and posed for a picture with them.

IMG_1869

History has a way of repeating itself. The sea horses again lost their home after 20 years. The Quay was demolished in 2007. This time the horses were rescued by citizens interested in seeing the icons returned to the community.

sea horse down

 

IMG_0272 - Version 2

In 2009 two sea horses were installed at Mote Marine Laboratory Aquarium in celebration of the opening of a new and fascinating exhibit on sea horses and to recognize the value Mote contributes to defining Sarasota as a unique and exceptional community. The year 2009 marked the third time the sea horses made a welcome appearance.

IMG_2494

Thanks to a generous donor another sea horse has reappeared and is permanently installed for all to enjoy at the Community Foundation of Sarasota County’s home on Fruitville Road.

IMG_1075

Another sea horse is now on temporary display along Palm Avenue, in front of the William Hartman Gallery.   It is becoming a popular photo backdrop for shoppers and strollers on the street.

IMG_2347

Sarasota’s majestic horses

75 years old!